
Ten strangers, each harboring a dark secret from their past, are invited under various pretexts to Soldier Island (formerly Indian Island/Nigger Island), an isolated mansion off the coast of Devon, England. Their host, a mysterious person named U.N. Owen ("Unknown"), is absent when they arrive. During their first evening together, a recorded voice plays from a phonograph, publicly accusing each of the ten guests of having committed a murder that escaped legal punishment. Shortly after, one guest dies from poisoning, triggering a nightmarish series of events. The guests notice framed copies of a classic nursery rhyme hanging in their rooms, along with ten small porcelain figurines on the dining table. As each guest is killed in a manner echoing the verses of the rhyme, one figurine vanishes. With no escape from the island due to a severe storm and no outside help coming, the survivors realize that the killer is one of them.